Five Pleasant Surprises and Three Disappointments in the Early Season Teams You Didn’t Expect

NFL Fantasy Football Surprises and Letdowns of the 2025 Season

Rising Stars: Unexpected Fantasy Football Performers

As we advance through the 2025 NFL season, fantasy football enthusiasts are witnessing several players stepping up in unexpected ways. These rising stars, often overlooked during preseason drafts, have proven to be valuable contributors. Below, El-Balad highlights some of the most impressive players who have exceeded expectations so far.

One such standout is Cam Skattebo, running back for the New York Giants. Skattebo has recently seen an increase in his game time and made a significant impact by scoring 24.1 fantasy points against the Kansas City Chiefs. With Tyrone Tracy Jr. sidelined due to a shoulder injury, Skattebo is expected to feature prominently in the Giants’ lineup, especially in their upcoming match against the Los Angeles Chargers. Skattebo’s dual-threat potential and impressive college career at Arizona State suggest he will continue to be a valuable fantasy asset.

Quentin Johnston Shines for the Chargers

Quentin Johnston, the wide receiver for the Los Angeles Chargers, is making a mark with his deep-ball prowess and rapid speed. Averaging 18.6 points per game and consistently receiving over seven targets, Johnston is proving essential to the Chargers’ offensive strategy. His play style has complemented Justin Herbert’s quarterbacking, offering a crucial vertical element that stretches defenses.

Daniel Jones’ Steady Growth with the Indianapolis Colts

Another player gaining attention is Daniel Jones, quarterback for the Indianapolis Colts. Despite a quieter performance in Week 3, Jones has shown maturity and improved accuracy under coach Shane Steichen. Completing 71.6% of his passes, Jones is making effective use of the Colts’ versatile receiving corps and has demonstrated his versatile playing style with three rushing touchdowns.

Unexpected Fantasy Football Triumphs

• Cam Skattebo, RB, New York Giants: Increased usage and significant points against the Chiefs.
• Quentin Johnston, WR, Los Angeles Chargers: Averaging 18.6 PPG with a key role in the passing offense.
• Daniel Jones, QB, Indianapolis Colts: Improved passing accuracy and three rushing touchdowns.

Hunter Henry: A Consistent TE Presence for the Patriots

The tight end position often confounds fantasy owners, but Hunter Henry from the New England Patriots has delivered dependable performances. Achieving double-digit fantasy points in multiple games, Henry has found his fit within Josh McDaniels’ system, becoming a key target for quarterback Drake Maye.

J.K. Dobbins Takes Charge in Denver

J.K. Dobbins, running back for the Denver Broncos, has emerged as the primary choice over rookie RJ Harvey. Averaging 15.2 points per game, Dobbins has consistently found the end zone in each appearance this season, securing his role as a reliable RB2/flex option under the leadership of coach Sean Payton.

Early-Season Disappointments

While some players have surprised with their stellar performances, others have not lived up to expectations. Marvin Harrison Jr., wide receiver for the Arizona Cardinals, started strong but has since struggled to maintain his production. Despite having the talent, Harrison’s recent performances have left fantasy owners questioning his consistency.

Challenges Facing Aston Jeanty and Brian Thomas Jr.

Ashton Jeanty, running back for the Las Vegas Raiders, is finding it difficult to replicate his preseason hype. Consistent game volume has not translated into significant points due to a struggling Raiders run game. Similarly, Brian Thomas Jr. of the Jacksonville Jaguars faces his challenges, with a worrying catch rate and persistent drops that have hampered his impact in fantasy lineups.

The ebb and flow of the NFL season continue to test the strategies of fantasy football managers. As players evolve, adapt, and sometimes stumble, staying informed and prepared to adjust lineups is crucial for securing success in fantasy leagues.