Strictly Judge Criticized for Controversial Comment on Karen Carney

A judge from BBC’s popular show, Strictly Come Dancing, has faced backlash over an insensitive comment regarding contestant Karen Carney’s health. Carney, a former footballer for England, has shared her struggles with Scheuermann’s disease. This spinal condition affects her ability to perform certain dance movements.

Background on Karen Carney

At 38, Carney has made a significant impact on English football, earning 144 caps for her country. She transitioned into a broadcasting career, working with networks like TNT Sports, Sky Sports, ITV, and Amazon Prime. Currently, she is a contestant on Strictly Come Dancing, partnering with professional dancer Carlos Gu.

Medical Disclosure and Its Implications

In a recent pre-performance video, Carney revealed that she has been living with Scheuermann’s disease since childhood. This condition leads to the abnormal growth of vertebrae, causing curvature in her spine. As she expressed:

• “I’ve had it since I was a kid; it’s a curve in my spine.”
• “It’s really hard for me to open my back up.”
• “There are certain elements that I just won’t be able to do, but Carlos is really supportive.”

Judges’ Reactions

Following her heartfelt revelation, Carney received mixed feedback from the show’s judges. Though Motsi Mabuse acknowledged Carney’s openness, she emphasized the need for dancers to challenge themselves to achieve specific postures in ballroom dance. Mabuse stated:

• “It’s going to be something that we have to challenge to see how far we can really stretch.”
• “Last week, you were top of the leaderboard, but this week I could feel the nerves.”

Viewer Backlash

Audiences reacted negatively to Mabuse’s comments. Many felt her suggestion to “challenge” Carney’s spinal issue was inappropriate. One viewer on social media expressed their disgust, citing the lack of empathy for Carney’s condition. Others shared their own experiences with spine curvature, calling Mabuse’s remarks ignorant and insensitive.

Conclusion

This incident illustrates the need for understanding and sensitivity towards contestants’ health issues, particularly in competitive environments. As Strictly Come Dancing continues, it’s essential that judges foster an encouraging atmosphere while being mindful of each contestant’s unique challenges.