Brewers Downplay Playoff Reunion with Former Manager Craig Counsell

The Milwaukee Brewers are gearing up for their matchup against the Chicago Cubs in the 2025 MLB playoffs, with Game 1 of the National League Division Series set for October 4. The upcoming series marks a significant moment as the Brewers will face off against their former manager, Craig Counsell, now leading the Cubs.
Brewers Prepare for Playoff Challenge
During media interactions on October 3, key Brewers players shared their thoughts on the upcoming matchup. Christian Yelich, a standout player, expressed humor regarding Counsell’s management style, mentioning, “It’s not like ‘Couns’ has exotic blitz packages.” This lighthearted remark reflects the confidence within the Brewers’ camp as they prepare for the intensity of playoff baseball.
Key Players and Coaching Dynamics
This year’s playoff roster is expected to include nine players who previously played under Counsell during the 2023 season. This list grows to ten with the inclusion of injured starter Brandon Woodruff. Woodruff emphasized the rivalry’s energy, stating, “Every Cubs-Brewers game is always pretty intense,” and anticipated an even more passionate atmosphere for the playoffs.
Since taking the helm after Counsell’s departure prior to the 2024 season, Pat Murphy has successfully led the Brewers to back-to-back division titles, including seasons with 93 and 97 wins. Both Yelich and outfielder Sal Frelick noted differences between Counsell and Murphy, recognizing their unique approaches to managing the game.
- Christian Yelich: Respected Counsell, but feels confident as the team prepares for the Cubs.
- P.at Murphy: Known for a more hands-on coaching style, leading to significant team success.
- Freddy Peralta: Committed to supporting his teammates amid expected boos from fans.
Anticipating Fan Reactions
As the series approaches, reactions from fans have been notable. Counsell has faced boos from Milwaukee fans during his returns to American Family Field. Peralta acknowledged the challenge of fan sentiment but emphasized the importance of maintaining focus on the game.
Brewers owner Mark Attanasio commented briefly on Counsell’s exit, stating that the manager did an “unbelievable job” during his nine seasons with the team. He reiterated that individual choices are made for personal and family well-being, underscoring the complexity of the situation.
Playoff Atmosphere and Expectations
The rivalry is expected to create a lively environment, with Cubs fans likely contributing to the crowd’s energy. Frelick recognized the dynamic, comparing it to other major league rivalries where fan presence is split.
Yelich added, “It’s two passionate fan bases that are familiar with each other.” The anticipation for competitive games is high, given the close nature of the teams during the regular season. As the Brewers look ahead, a thrilling playoff experience is anticipated for both teams and their dedicated fans.